Skip to main content

The Selective Memory of Men: The Truth About Polygamy in Islam

 


It's almost comical how some men conveniently cherry-pick religious texts to justify their desires. The claim that Islam "allows" men to marry four wives is a classic example of selective reading. The reality? The Qur'an sets conditions-strict conditions-that most men today wouldn't even come close to fulfilling.

Polygamy Was Never About Men's Desires

When people (by people I mean men) bring up Qur'an an-Nisa 4:3, they conveniently ignore the context. This verse was revealed at a time when war had left many women widowed, and polygamy was meant to protect them, not cater to men's fantasies. Yet, somehow, modern interpretations have twisted this into:

"It's in a man's nature to desire multiple women"

Really? Since when did religion exist to indulge human nature instead of controlling it? Almost every major faith teaches discipline over desire--whether it's fasting, prayer, modesty, or even simple self-restraint. But suddenly, when it comes to polygamy, some men act like the Qur'an was written to validate their urges.

Fairness: A Condition They Pretend to Ignore

The second condition? Absolute fairness. The Qur'an says if a man fears he cannot be just, he should marry only one. But here's where it get's interesting:
You will never be able to be fair and just between women, even if it is your ardent desire. Qur'an an-Nisa 4:129

God Himself says men cannot be fair. Yet, some still claim they can. The audacity!!

So, if justice is impossible, why do so many men still insist they can pull it off? Simple: they ignore the definite and focus on the ambiguous.

The Heart's Sickness: Twisting Scripture For Personal Gain

The Qur'an itself warns about people who deliberately focus on the unspecific verses while ignoring the definitive ones. Instead of following the core message, they dig around for loopholes--ways to make the Qur'an fit their desires instead of shaping their desire around the Qur'an.

This is not about faith. It's about self-interest disguised as religious obedience.

May God forgive us for our shortcomings. Because if we are being honest, the real issue here isn't polygamy-it's the intellectual dishonesty of those who manipulate religion to suit their personal wants.

If we truly followed the Qur'an in spirit and not just in selective wording, many so-called "religious" arguments would collapse. But hey, as they say, ignorance is bliss.

Or in this case--convenient.

Comments

  1. It's own personal decision . Actually we all have knowledge , understanding and wisdom given to us freely. Its not in any particular religion that this happens, people have a tendency of interpreting the books to fit our selfish lifestyle . Ours is to always source for the truth and it will always set us free.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Exactly, we cannot blindly make terrible decisions backed with flimsy excuses. These intentional errors do have grave consequences.
      Source for the truth and it will set you free.
      Well put Maggie

      Delete
  2. This has illuminated light on this particular topic.

    The important question is this: is it justified to then marry a window/s ?

    Thanks for writing on this topic ✍️

    ReplyDelete
  3. As long as you do not oppress them, and you will be fair.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

From Teenage Pregnancy to Recovery: My Journey of Struggle, Support, and Empowerment

 I never thought I would become a mother at such a young age. When I found out I was pregnant, my world changed instantly. The father of my child wasn’t there in those early years, and while that was difficult, I was blessed to have my family by my side. Their unwavering support kept me going, even when the road felt uncertain. Years later, the father of my child and his family—his mother, brother, and sister—began to step in and help. Their support, though delayed, made a difference, reminding me that people can change and that help sometimes comes when you least expect it. My journey through young motherhood inspired me to do more for girls and young mothers facing similar struggles. This is why I became heavily involved with Protect a Girl’s Image Organization —to ensure no young mother feels alone and that every child gets the chance to grow up in a supportive environment. The Reality of Teenage Motherhood Being a teenage mother is a challenge, even with family support. Society...

Why Your Kids Aren’t Listening: The Truth About Communication, Discipline, and Setting a Better Example

 Children need adults to teach, guide and support them as they grow and learn but why is it that every time I say NO,  my baby bursts into flames? Usually, it starts with them asking "Kwa nini?" And one thing I have learnt quite painfully as most of my fellow mothers would relate, telling them "It's because I said so" is the worst mistake any parent would ever commit. Before you vehemently descend on me, hear me out. Most of the time this response slides quite easily from our tongues. If you don't know better it will seem an easier option as an answer instead of the whole trying to explain debacle. Right??..... WRONG!! But why does this happen? I find it more as a curiosity issue in a child and quite sincerely they don't understand negation. For example "Don't hit your sister" sounds more like "hit your sister" to our adorable munchkin's ears, because it is usually what they end up doing since their developing minds don't ...